Why Didn’t All the Aid Reach the Poorest? Here’s Why…

Posted on Monday, February 11th, 2013 at 1:37 pm

By Julia Lewis, Area Manager, Democratic Republic of Congo, Concern Worldwide

Concern staff prepare kits for distribution

When academics or the media criticize aid organizations for inefficiencies or promises unfulfilled, I can’t help but think about the vast and endlessly tangled complexities of this work.  Crisis follows crisis, harsh realities are compounded by harsh realities, and every day there are situations where we are forced to take decisions when no option offers the perfect solution.

That’s often the case here in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), the epicenter of what was called ‘Africa’s World War’ (1998-2003), the deadliest conflict since World War II, and especially in the eastern reaches of the country where violence and terror have continued since the supposed end of that war.  Conflict and preventable disease continue to take the lives of tens of thousands each month—five years ago a fellow international organization here put the toll at over five million.  The situation has little changed since then.

In November, the M23 rebel group invaded Goma, a city in the country’s war-torn east. The Congolese army put up little resistance, leaving it largely for their taking. When they first took over, upwards of 100,000 people fled their homes, often leaving everything behind to seek refuge in official camps, churches, and schools—anywhere that provided some semblance of safety.

Harsh reality #1: 100,000 people are displaced and in urgent need, in a province where approximately 400,000 more people were already displaced by conflict.  

Concern and other NGOs unload NFIs to the distribution site

People needed everything with which to eke out a basic existence away from home, from food to medicine, blankets, clothes, and kitchen utensils. When the M23 took over, we at Concern Worldwide immediately started preparations together with other organizations to provide kits containing basic households goods (or as we call them, non-food items, NFI) such as blankets, jerry cans, plastic sheeting, kitchen sets, sleeping mats, clothes, and women’s hygiene kits. These items would help families to keep warm and dry, to prepare food, to wash themselves and their clothes, and to store water.

Unfortunately, our plans were stalled by reports of lootings and rapes in and around the sites.  A constant struggle in reaching people in need is the fact that order is hard to come by in DRC where multiple armed groups operate.  It would have been impossible to hide that we were planning a large-scale distribution and to carry on in such circumstances would have simply added fuel to the flames and placed those we were supposed to be helping, as well as our own staff, at unacceptable risk.  Frustrating as it was, we were left with little choice but to hold out until the camps could be secured by the police and UN peacekeepers.

Harsh Reality #2: Aid often has to be targeted to the poorest and most in need, amidst a population who are often barely better off.

To make sure our aid reached those most in need, approximately 100 people, Concern staff among them, set off while it was still dark one Tuesday morning to different camps around Goma to try and count people while they were still fast asleep and before anyone else could arrive and pretend they too were living there. With an understanding of how many people were in each camp, it was decided that Concern was responsible for distributing to 6,000 families in Mugunga 1, a camp on the western outskirts of Goma.

Concern registers beneficiaries at distribution site

Meanwhile, back at base, Concern’s office suddenly resembled a mixture between a builder’s yard and Santa’s workshop. Trucks loaded with goods came and went. Our logistics team worked frantically and tirelessly to prepare thousands of kits—each of which contained 20 items—and every square inch was covered with tarpaulin-wrapped piles of blankets, plastic sheeting, second-hand clothing, soap, jerry cans, and sleeping mats.

After all this preparation and planning, the first day of the distribution finally arrived.

My alarm went off at 4:30 am. By dawn we were already setting up the distribution site, creating separate areas for people to line up, be marked off the distribution list, and receive their items. As the team got to work, the mood lifted suddenly when a generator was set up and loud Congolese and Nigerian pop music blasted through speakers. A group of 30 kids gathered around, dancing in time to the beat. With such a festive mood, my tiredness suddenly evaporated. Within a couple of hours, the real work began and by the end of the first day, some 1,500 households received assistance. By the second day, we reached 1,713 more. This left some 2,800 households to be served on the last day—an ambitious, but not impossible, target.

Harsh Reality #3: External forces, especially insecurity, often delay assistance or prevent us from reaching those most in need.

The last day of any distribution is always the most difficult and highlights some of the challenges in providing humanitarian assistance. There is an awareness that the end is nearing.  As more and more bystanders gathered near the site, tensions ran high and by lunchtime, they were palpable. Our job now was to get the distribution done as quickly and calmly as possible.

Recipients carry relief items at Concern's distribution in Goma

Despite the presence of the national police and a UN peace-keeping force, the situation was deteriorating and we decided to suspend the distribution until security could be guaranteed.  To try to finish it would only have put everyone there, ourselves and most of all the people we were there to help, in possible harm’s way.  With around 700 households still to be served, it was difficult to leave the job unfinished, but we were left with little choice.

It was impossible not to feel deflated after being so close to reaching all 6,000 households, even though the situation was out of our control. I tried instead to focus on the 5,300 households that we did reach, and knew that planning would start immediately to make a second attempt to reach them. Indeed, a second registration process is underway and these households will soon be receiving assistance.

Harsh Reality #4: As long as the constant crisis that is the DRC goes unnoticed by the rest of the world, Concern and our partners will continue to struggle to provide life-saving relief, let alone work hand-in-hand with communities to achieve lasting change.

Since our distribution, a relative calm has settled in over Goma, but the situation remains volatile.  While the M23 are no longer in control of Goma, they are stationed just four kilometers away and armed groups elsewhere in the Kivus continue to aggravate any hope for peace. All eyes are on the negotiations that are underway in Kinshasa between M23 and the government but what the outcome will be is anyone’s guess. What is clear is that the situation could deteriorate again at any moment, provoking further suffering and reinforcing the cycle of conflict and violence that communities, women and children here have suffered for decades.

 

 

Bookmark and Share
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply

*